Maybe this will help everyone with the RB debate. I'm a Buckeyes fan, but I'm not sure they would be #1 in my book, though the point of consistency with the program and the talent is valid. Until last year, they were one of the few holdouts sticking with a power running Offense. USC certainly has the star power, but looking back through the years, there was a major drought of talent and consistency at USC.
Running Back U. - Top All-Around RB Schools
OSU's list doesn't even include a few old timers from the 40's/50's who were Heisman Trophy Winners: Howard "Hopalong" Cassady, Vic Janowicz and Les Horvath. Probably not what traditional RB's these days are considered, but still RB's in their day.